How to Invent an Institution

Beyond the Canvas: Exhibition Review
New Taipei City Art Museum
Gallery 6A
October 17, 2026 to February 14, 2027



On a recent visit to Taichung for the Asia Art Biennial, I had the opportunity to have a nice Sunday lunch with the family of the woman I’ve been dating for some time. During the meal, her uncle asked me a curious question: If anything were to happen to Taiwan in a military conflict with China, would I take her back to the United States with me in case of an evacuation of U.S. citizens and their dependents? According to him, it wouldn’t be possible if I were Japanese because Japan doesn’t evacuate non-Japanese dependents. Was this actually true? After a bit of research, it seems like…it depends. I was left wondering why Japan’s evacuation policies are a meaningful point of comparison to that of the U.S. Perhaps the question is a reflection of the complexity with which some Taiwanese view their post-colonial relationship with Japan. As far as I understand it, opinions are mixed, perhaps not quite as negative as one would expect. Looking into the past is one way to frame the present. Some argue that post-war Taiwan is part of the American empire, given the country’s essential role in the fight for global technological dominance in the age of artificial intelligence and the need to protect the island nation’s technical infrastructure. Of course, it’s also possible that he was just trying to gauge the depth of our relationship. What are some of the other “benefits” of being a vassal state within an empire beyond purely military or economic engagement? While the exchange can be patronizing at best and murderously exploitative at worst, within Taiwanese history there exists another possibility if we consider the realm of fine arts. 

At least that’s what it would seem after viewing New Taipei City Art Museum’s (NCTAM) recent exhibition, Beyond the Canvas, which explores the respective legacies and practices of major Taiwanese artists, Li Mei-shu, Yang San-lang, and Li Shih-chiao. The show is primarily concerned with highlighting the stunning skill with which the three men worked as they embraced Western painting styles ranging from Impressionism to Cubism, Surrealism, and Abstract Expressionism. It is hard to look past the dazzling paintings on display and, at times, the sharpness with which they capture daily life as it unfolds before each artist. To the average viewer, it can all be neatly tied up with a bow. Done and dusted. In the context of NTCAMs overall programming, this exhibition is the second of three currently on show at the museum that explore the work of earlier generations of artists in Taiwan, weaving together their stories in an attempt to establish a larger narrative about the development of art on the island among its settler populations and amidst subsequent colonial regimes. Would these artists have lent themselves to the settler colonial project at hand? Or is it a convenient story that binds together a handful of exceptionally talented artists that might otherwise might have actually been much more self-interested? Admittedly, these shows do represent a refreshing expansion of the museum’s examination of foundational artists and creatives that have shaped art in Taiwan across painting, photography, and publications. It truly is an impressive act of storytelling that illuminates the reality of how these artists lived. Yet at the same time it ends up leaving a bigger question about how that narrative is connected to the present.  

All three painters are regarded as part of the first generation of great artists to emerge from the nation in the 1920s and 1930s. They are also credited with having formed the vanguard of the post-war national art scene amidst the rise of the Kuomintang. Each studied in Japan, with both Shih-chiao and Mei-shu contemporaries and roommates at the Tokyo School of Fine Arts. Both studied privately under the tutelage of Yoshimura Yoshimatsu, a Japanese Western-style painter whose work was selected multiple times for the Japanese Imperial Art Academy Exhibition (Teiten) as well as the Ministry of Education’s Art Exhibition (Bunten). Shih-chiao would eventually exhibit in the Teiten six times, eventually earning exemption from jury screening, such was the depth of his connection to the endeavor. What does it mean that the individuals considered to be Taiwan’s first generation of great artists were nurtured and eventually celebrated in the heart of the Japanese imperial project? Did these artists actually see themselves as part of a larger movement of Taiwanese artists the way they are portrayed? It is hard to separate individuals from their circumstances and it’s difficult to imagine that they would have positioned themselves as politically opposed to Taiwan’s then-occupiers. Would they really have proposed their existence as a supposed collective as a meaningful pillar to a still developing Taiwanese national cultural identity? We don’t get much of an answer to these questions and are instead treated to an abundance of paintings that seem to suggest that what is important to focus on is how talented these artists were. 

The exhibition opens with an elevation viewing of three exemplary paintings: Li Shi-chiao’s Portrait of the Fourth Younger Brother, an emotional, contemplative, and somewhat tragic portrait of his sibling; Li Mei-shu’s Red Dress, a striking portrayal of a young woman that perhaps offers a bit more of an intimate peek into the painter’s relationships than the text suggests; and Yang San-lang’s Still Life which brings forth a sweet, luscious, and delicate scene hinting at the artist’s examination of place. 

Li Shi-chiao’s oeuvre is portrayed as the most stylistically expansive, with the inclusion of works such as the surreal Deep in the Night with its melancholy, meditative scene rife with thought-provoking spatial incursions that pull the audience deeper in. Then there is Port, featuring shapes that dance in such a lively and dynamic way as to almost obscure the harbor if not for a sea in the top left corner, so intensely abstracted are the elements. Beauties at the Lake Shore is in direct conversation with Cezanne’s Les Grande Baigneuses and Picasso’s Les Demoiselles d’Avignon. The exhibition makes repeated overtures to Li’s legacy extending to his private studio, where he was seen as a standard bearer despite a somewhat heretical pursuit of experimentation with Western styles while guiding cohorts of young artists, yet we are not treated to even a minor sampling of work from his disciples currently in practice. 

Li Mei-shu seems to be most connected to daily life of the three, with the selection of his paintings suggesting that he truly was a brilliant stenographer of Taiwanese life through his vibrant figurative work. Fall in the Yard depicts a young woman gently reclining in a garden. Its explosion of color in the background responds to the patterns in her dress as she enjoys afternoon tea. Chanting the Buddhist Scriptures vividly illustrates a group of women solemnly praying at Sanxia Zaishu Temple. Bright red lanterns illuminate the worshippers’ faces, their eyes closed in deep concentration. Their hands, tightly holding offerings, also fall under the warm glow. It is apt that the painter would create such a strong depiction of devotion in such a setting. This particular scene functions as somewhat of a mirror, as Li would eventually dedicate himself with similar intensity to the rebuilding of nearby Zushi Sanxia Temple, bringing his own aesthetic interpretation of spiritual and religious themes into the physical structure and at times inviting other artists and artisans to participate in the process. The show dedicates significant space to drawings, materials, correspondence, and decorative structural elements illuminating the work put into the project. It is an interesting thread to pull on curatorially and helpful in expanding our view of Li’s legacy.

Yang San-lang comes off as a master of landscape due to the extensive number of paintings on the subject of the environment sans humans on display. Kingfisher, with its lush, textured strokes bring the wetlands to life, the lone bird’s blue body brightly contrasted against various greens interrupted by floral bursts. Two versions of Tamsui are on display, aptly titled “Old” and “New” showing the painter’s desire to revisit the quiet town scene, subtly reworking it and offering a fresh perspective. Yang is also heralded as the main figure in the Taiyang Art Association, the largest, oldest, and longest continuously operating independent art organization in Taiwan. Known for having “played a significant role in the development of Taiwanese art”, it hosts exhibition competitions, juries, and awards, an approach that it has pursued since 1934. It is odd that the show doesn’t dedicate more space to highlight this particular institution despite mentioning it multiple times. In fact, an extension of the show could have included an auxiliary space with direct references to the impact this particular school has on the contemporary scene, highlighted similarly to Li Mei-shu’s work with Zushi Sanxia Temple. But upon further examination into the present reality of Taiyang Art Association’s present state, it becomes clear why: it is irrelevant and antiquated. It is here that the exhibition ultimately falls short and is caught in a problematic attempt to fabricate a past in dialogue with the present.

The Taiyang Art Association still produces exhibitions and holds open calls to this day. Artists can submit work for consideration only in categories such as oil painting, gouache, ink painting, sculpture, watercolor, and printmaking. But are open calls and a yearly exhibition a meaningful way to support and build an art community? Would they have been in the 1940s and 1950s? At best, they are passive activities that don't suggest serious engagement with the vast landscape of up-and-coming artists that make up the present and future of Taiwan’s art scene. Additionally, if art is a process of investigation, research, taking the old, trying the new, rejecting the old, searching for new ideas, experimentation, flouting norms, why are the organization’s frameworks for consideration so narrow? Given the expansive number of mediums employed in art production in Taiwan today, it would seem that there should be an adjustment to meet the times and include more mediums for artists to present work. Finally, a glance at the current membership also reveals that the average individual is much closer to the end of their career than the beginning. Wouldn’t an organization invested in developing and supporting talent in an art ecosystem have a greater proportion of younger artists? Today, many young contemporary artists in Taiwan seem to feel that the only way to have a successful career is to leave Taiwan. How does the Taiyang Art Association work to counteract that drive? 100 years ago, Li Mei-shu, Yang San-lang, and Li Shih-chiao (among many others) felt similarly, either going to Japan or Europe to develop their respective practices and careers. They did not feel that there was much in the way of support or opportunity domestically, otherwise they would have stayed. While they did return, their reputations were already relatively secure, having achieved acclaim internationally. 

Art history is not made by simply changing how you view the past. As Taiwan continues the challenging and neverending work of developing its arts institutions, it is clear that the stories contributing to the narrative of what Taiwan’s art was, is, and will be are still in contention. The same is true for all modern nations. There is no need to invent a glorious past that revolves around “heroic” artists that, despite their circumstances, supposedly managed to forge a unique and insurgent cultural identity that was somehow anti-imperial yet celebrated but also ruggedly independent in a way that suits today’s perspectives. It is perfectly possible to accept that great artists were a product of their time and appreciate them as such, without making them unwilling forbearers to a contemporary landscape on which their fingerprints can hardly be seen. Co-opting specific individuals or ideas to provide a desperately needed cultural center at a time when identity is in flux reveals more questions than it answers and trends dangerously towards a perspective of art that harms more than it helps.